Archive for September, 2010

I Do Not Know What to do About This

By Nate Reaven

I do not know what to do about this.

This past weekend one of my students was shot through the chest. Apparently, a family friend turned enemy entered into my student’s house at 2:00 am, killed the father, and shot my student, who is currently in the hospital but should be physically okay within a couple of weeks.

What do I say? How do I react?

How do I change? What do I change?  Do I change?

We passed out notes to our class and had them write a get-better soon note to the student. His friends and favorite teachers went to visit him at the hospital and saw that he was in high spirits. What do I say? Sorry? Is that enough to make it better? Is that ever enough?

How do I act? Like nothing happened? “Move along class, there is nothing to see here. Please turn to page 218 in your books.”

Is this just something that happens? Should I have expected something different?

How do I change? Do I teach differently now? Do I let up, let them slide a little bit more, let them get away with talking out of turn? Or, should my class become stricter, teach them discipline instead of grammar, life skills in place of quality of living?

What do I change? Do I change the way I teach? Change the way I interact with my students? My mother said something interesting to me. She said the teachers that make it into the movies are not the ones teaching grammar every morning. They are the teachers who make the classroom a place of social well-being, a place of comfort –first. The teachers that focus on creating self-confidence as the learning target. The movie teachers are those teachers that consider the the academic goals, not secondary, but certainly second priority. How much do those movie-teachers actually teach? Do their students walk away from their classrooms more intelligent, more confident or both? Do those students get shot at 2:00 am in the morning?

Do I change? I had nothing to do with what happened, and there is nothing I could have done to prevent what happened. Maybe I should not feel any sense of obligation at all. On the other hand, the reason I got into teaching was to make a difference.  What kind of difference?

I do not know what to do about this.

Back on Board

by Eric Benzel

Hello, again, North to South Friends.

It has been a while since my last post, as August was a month off for my program here. We started classes last week, and I am back in ‘business’ as it were. I start observations at schools around the city this week and am excited to be bringing you all many stories of success and failure. Until then, I thought I would post a brief update of the important news from the last month that will be affecting my career as a teacher here in NYC.

The month started with lots of reflection as I considered what I would do if my own ‘value-added’ metrics were published in a major local newspaper (if interested, read a high-powered response. Later I celebrated with fellow New Yorkers at the news that NY won just under $700 million in funding from Race to the Top (sorry Colorado). A New Yorker turned Coloradan wrote a letter about his own doubts about the reform conversation (ala Diane Ravitch). Honestly, I keep going back and forth. Last night I attended a small, yet well publicized gathering of teachers that added to my confusions. Perhaps most importantly, New York passed comprehensive anti-bullying legislation including sexual orientation and gender identity (only the 10th state to do so).

Now, September.

Who Are We In This Complicated World?

by Janessa Jordan

Technically, I have been working on this blog since Wednesday. Wednesday was the first day that I was really overwhelmingly frustrated in the classroom. My students were yelling, disengaged, and disrespectful. I had collected homework which demonstrated my students’ lack of understanding and lack of general will to work hard.

In my frustration, I wrote a post that was full of hopelessness. It called out the education system that breeds disengagement and a lack of hope in my students. By not providing the necessary time, resources, and manpower that my students need in order to really learn, my students have learned how to skate by and how their voices don’t really matter in the grand scheme of things.

Those thoughts saddened me so. I have always been such a dreamer–hopeful about the positive change that I can make in my students’ lives. Yet, for the first time I was allowing my frustrations about the system and my own teaching abilities to smother the hope that I’d built up for all of the years that I’ve been longing to be a teacher.

Then, as I was finishing planning my unit on the Kite Runner, I stumbled upon this poem by Rumi:


Who are we in this complicated world?

if we come to sleep
we are His drowsy ones.

and if we come to wake
we are in His hands.

if we come to weeping,
we are His cloud full of raindrops.

and if we come to laughing,
we are His lightning in that moment.

if we come to anger and battle,
it is the reflection of His wrath.

and if we come to peace and pardon,
it is the reflection of His love.

who are we in this complicated world?

************************************

I was so humbled by this poem. I get to choose how to cope with my students’ lack of motivation, my students’ far-below-grade-level abilities, and the education system’s ongoing barrage of legislation which seems to penalize teachers and kill creativity in students (see http://www.ted.com/talks/ken_robinson_says_schools_kill_creativity.html) . Regardless of what circumstances I have been given, I can still choose how to react. However I choose to respond, my heart ultimately carries momentum in the world, beyond myself and my own classroom, and into a school and a system that desperately deserves positivity and hope.

Here’s to Monday: A brand new day in a brand new week with a brand new attitude. In this complicated world, I choose to “come to peace and pardon.”

Remembering Who I Am

By Garrett Hedman

In the first orientation with my school district, I learned that I would be sized up. That students will look at me, judge me, and ask, “How far can I push him? How much can I really learn from him?” A large, kind football coach reassured me, “and looking at you…yeah, you’ll get sized up.” So now the question becomes, how much am I willing to change so when students size me up they realize they can’t push me around; they have to learn in my classroom? How much am I willing to change for the sake of educating others?

Now, I’ve got the face. It took me a while, but I learned it—the cold-hearted, nothing you say or do will disrupt me, I’m here to teach and teach alone, don’t mess with me face. Never in my life have I felt the need to learn such a look. Never in my life have I wanted to learn such a look, but as every good species does, I adapted to my environment.

For those readers that know me, this may come to no surprise, but I could only play this game for so long. Two weeks into the school year my insides would churn just driving up to the school where I had to be someone I didn’t want to be. This churning had driven other teachers out of the school. Three Teach for America teachers, had quit within those first few weeks for many reasons, but from what I’ve heard, a lot of it came from that “churning stomach”*.

Dissatisfied with how I was feeling, one day after school I decided to run on the Mississippi levy. Two steps on the levy and I felt my body explode with energy. It seemed like every step I took was a release of the person I had become and a release of the frustration of that change. The facade I built around me began to shed with that run, and by the end, I once again felt like I was showing the true skin of Garrett. For the first time in the school year, I felt like life was going to turn around.

It was soon after that run, I had some of my best days in the classroom. I decided to be myself—laugh and love, but it was all centered in the context of urgent education. At first the students were confused, but I felt great, and I think they were happier knowing the teacher was happier. Inappropriate behavior or partial commitment to education was not tolerated in the classroom because we would be denying ourselves an opportunity to grow.

I have run 4-5 days a week since this turn around as a reminder of who I am.

I still have poor days, generally when my lessons are poor, and I have wonderful days, generally when I prepare wonderful lessons, but at the end of the day, I try to be comfortable in who I am and what I’ve done.

So as I sit with my feet in an oxbow lake of the Mississippi river and as the sun paints its colors in the sky through a sunset, I feel lucky, lucky that this world may not just be adapting to one’s environment, but also, perhaps even more importantly, allowing the environment adapt to you.

* This is a high rate of leave from TFA teachers in an area and does not represent the actual rate of drop out.